Loretta Young
Sister Margaret
Celeste Holm
Sister Scholastica
Hugh Marlowe
Robert Masen
Elsa Lanchester
Amelia Potts
Thomas Gomez
Luigi Rossi
Dorothy Patrick
Kitty
Basil Ruysdael
The Bishop
Dooley Wilson
Anthony James
Regis Toomey
Monsignor Talbot
Mike Mazurki
Sam
Walter Baldwin
Claude Jarman (uncredited)
Pati Behrs
Nun (uncredited)
John Bleifer
Rosey (uncredited)
Nan Boardman
Nun (uncredited)
Wally Brown
Howard Sheldon (uncredited)
Russ Clark
Policeman (uncredited)
Louise Colombet
Nun (uncredited)
Teddy Driver
Cherub (uncredited)
Robert Foulk
New York City Policeman (uncredited)
Gordon Gebert
Willie Matthews (uncredited)
Eula Guy
Mrs. O'Connor (uncredited)
Louis Jean Heydt
Al Newman (uncredited)
Tim Huntley
Buzz Townsend-Cooper (uncredited)
Danny Jackson
George (Jarman's Assistant) (uncredited)
Virginia Keiley
Mrs. Townsend-Cooper (uncredited)
Nolan Leary
Bethlehem Station Master (uncredited)
Henri Letondal
Father Barraud (uncredited)
Ian MacDonald
Mr. Matthews (uncredited)
Marion Martin
Rossi's Manicurist (uncredited)
Edwin Max
Whitey (uncredited)
Roddy McCaskill
Cherub (uncredited)
Gary Pagett
Johnnie Matthews (uncredited)
Jean Prescott
Mrs. Matthews (uncredited)
Yvette Reynard
Nun (uncredited)
Frank Richards
Lefty (uncredited)
Loulette Sablon
Nun (uncredited)