Phil Vischer
Sheriff/Prince John/Bill Scarlet/Friar Cluck/Little John(voice)
Mike Nawrocki
Robin Good (Larry)/Serf (Jerry)/Big Red (Jean Claude) (voice)
Lisa Vischer
Lenny (Junior)/Mom Asparagus (singing) (voice)
J. Chris Wall
Dad Asparagus (voice)
Keri Pisapia
Mom Asparagus (speaking)/Laura Carrot/Miss Lewis (voice)
Jim Poole
Scooter Carrot (voice)
Charlotte Volkman Jackson
Miss Achmetha (voice)
Maggie Roberts
Annie (voice)
Megan Murphy
Libby Asparagus (voice)
Brian K. Roberts
Scallion #3 (voice)
Marco Antonio Pulk
Eddie Espinosa (voice)
Dustin Ballard
Gatekeeper/Giant (voice)
Laura Neutzling
Gooseberry Singer (voice)
Josiah Mok
Little Nate (voice)
Zoe Mok
Little Sister (voice)
Sarah Vorhees Wendel
Village Heckler (voice)