Mira Sorvino
Elaine
Joe Pantoliano
Oswald
Ryan Simpkins
Lizzy Muldoun
Michael Urie
James
Maxwell Beer
Jeremy Fink
Steve Grodewald
Tattooed guy
Ryan Glassman
Rick
Christopher King
Garlic Man
Amelia Bullock
Girl Scout
Evan Trevor Thompson
Clay
Marian Seldes
Mabel Billingsly
Heather Braverman
Samantha
Roscoe Orman
Dr. Grady
Betsy Brandt
Madame Zaleski
Seth Kanor
Jeremy's Dad (voice)
Daniel Cosgrove
Herb Muldoun
Mike Starr
Officer Polansky
Gavin Furbert
Security Guard
Markley Rizzi
Mary
Nimo Gandhi
Fred
Michael Pemberton
Doorman
Joe Huu
Shady Character #1
Eddie Perry
Shady Character #2
David Thornton
Simon Rudolph
Jacob Michel
Cassius
Wendy Mass
Wendy
Gary Allen
Larry
Ngo Okafor
Sebastian
Bill Walters
Homeless Dude